Jeg kiggede lidt på det og de to regexp's minder meget om hinanden - den primære forskel er vist at du bruger \w i stedet for a-z. Der er ingen tvivl om at det er et godt script du har lavet, men der er alligvel en del huller i forhold til specifikationen.
Fra:
http://www.dwheeler.com/secure-programs/Secure-Programs-HOWTO/input.htmlA full email address checker is actually quite complicated, because there are legacy formats that greatly complicate validation if you need to support all of them; see mailaddr(7) and IETF RFC 822 [RFC 822] for more information if such checking is necessary. Friedl [1997] developed a regular expression to check if an email address is valid (according to the specification); his ``short'' regular expression is 4,724 characters, and his ``optimized'' expression (in appendix B) is 6,598 characters long. And even that regular expression isn't perfect; it can't recognize local email addresses, and it can't handle nested parentheses in comments (as the specification permits). Often you can simplify and only permit the ``common'' Internet address formats.
Hvis du kaster et blik på:
http://www.perl.com/CPAN/authors/Tom_Christiansen/scripts/ckaddr.gzKan du se et eksempel på en checker som i højere grad lever op til RFC822 - men stadig har mangler...